Abdel- Moniem I El-Khateeb, Gamal A Makhlouf, Ahmed M Khalfallah
Eslam M. Ibrahim, Tamer A. Alnaimy and Mohammed Elkilanty
Abdelrahim A. Abdelrahim, Farouk A. Mourad, Mostafa A. Hamad, Ahmed M. Ali, Ahmed M. Ibrahim, Mohmoud R. Shehata, Ragai S. Hanna
Mostafa A. Elshazli, Mohamed D. Sarhan, Ahmed AbdAl Aziz, Mohamed.H.Khattab
Salah Soliman, Tamer Elgabary, EL Ashraf Thabet, Mahmoud Badawy
Abd Elhafez M. Elsheweal1, Ayman F. Ahmed2, Hala Y. Yousef2,Raafat Hegazy3, and Ahmed F. Elsaid4
Ahmed S. Mohammed, Mahmoud R. Shehata, Abd Elmoniem I. El-khateeb, Hany A. Ali, Tarek A. Mostafa, Ragai S. Hanna
Hany Mohamed (MD), Ashraf Goda (MD), Hatem Mohammed (MD)
Shaban M. Abdel Mageed
Mohamed M.E Ibrahem2,*, Shaban M. Abdel Mageed1,*, and Shawki M.K Sharouda1
Ahmed Morad, MD; Yasser El Ghamrini, MD
Ahmed Morad, MD; Ahmed Aly, MD; Hossam El Sadek, MD
Yasser Hussein1, Hazem Nour1, Dauda Bawa3, Mansour Morsy1, Salah Mansour1, Saleem Abdulsattar2, Medhat Mustafa2,Wael lotfy1
Mohammad Ahmad Abdel Gawad, Osama Ahmed Radwan, Ahmed Abdel Aal, Mohamed Gamal Eldin
Amr A A Mostafa Elkatatny MD, MSc., PhD1, Tarek M Hamdy MD, MSc., PhD1,Abdrabou N Mashhour MD, MSc., PhD2
Evaluation of Harmonic Scalpel vs Ligasure Device in Thyroidectomy: A Prospective Randomized Study in a Tertiary Care Center
The harmonic scalpel HS (Johnson & Johnson®) and LigaSure LS (COVIDIEN®) are new technologies
that have been introduced in the surgical treatment of thyroid diseases during recent years. The aim of this
study is to evaluate the use of HS and LS in total thyroidectomy operation as regards the time of the
operation, postoperative complications and duration of hospital stay. In the current study, 70 patients
underwent total thyroidectomy for simple multinodular and toxic goitre in the period between June 2016
and June 2017. In all patients, total thyroidectomy was performed through a classic Kocher s incision. The
harmonic scalpel was implemented on Group A (35 patients), while Group B (35 patients) were operated
with Ligasure device. Both Groups were evaluated for the time of the operation, intra-operative and
postoperative complications and the duration of hospital stay. The two Groups had similar demographics,
thyroid pathology and type of operative procedure. In the present study, there was no statistically
significant difference between the two Groups regarding the operative time, intra- and postoperative
complications and duration of hospital stay. Conclusion: Both Harmonic scalpel and Ligasure device are
safe and effective devices in total thyroidectomy operation for benign Goitre.
Keywords: Harmonic Scalpel; Ligasure Device; Hypocalcaemia; hemostasis; total Thyroidectomy.