Abdel- Moniem I El-Khateeb, Gamal A Makhlouf, Ahmed M Khalfallah
Eslam M. Ibrahim, Tamer A. Alnaimy and Mohammed Elkilanty
Abdelrahim A. Abdelrahim, Farouk A. Mourad, Mostafa A. Hamad, Ahmed M. Ali, Ahmed M. Ibrahim, Mohmoud R. Shehata, Ragai S. Hanna
Mostafa A. Elshazli, Mohamed D. Sarhan, Ahmed AbdAl Aziz, Mohamed.H.Khattab
Salah Soliman, Tamer Elgabary, EL Ashraf Thabet, Mahmoud Badawy
Abd Elhafez M. Elsheweal1, Ayman F. Ahmed2, Hala Y. Yousef2,Raafat Hegazy3, and Ahmed F. Elsaid4
Ahmed S. Mohammed, Mahmoud R. Shehata, Abd Elmoniem I. El-khateeb, Hany A. Ali, Tarek A. Mostafa, Ragai S. Hanna
Hany Mohamed (MD), Ashraf Goda (MD), Hatem Mohammed (MD)
Shaban M. Abdel Mageed
Mohamed M.E Ibrahem2,*, Shaban M. Abdel Mageed1,*, and Shawki M.K Sharouda1
Ahmed Morad, MD; Yasser El Ghamrini, MD
Ahmed Morad, MD; Ahmed Aly, MD; Hossam El Sadek, MD
Yasser Hussein1, Hazem Nour1, Dauda Bawa3, Mansour Morsy1, Salah Mansour1, Saleem Abdulsattar2, Medhat Mustafa2,Wael lotfy1
Mohammad Ahmad Abdel Gawad, Osama Ahmed Radwan, Ahmed Abdel Aal, Mohamed Gamal Eldin
Amr A A Mostafa Elkatatny MD, MSc., PhD1, Tarek M Hamdy MD, MSc., PhD1,Abdrabou N Mashhour MD, MSc., PhD2
Utility of Commonly Used Preoperative Diagnostic Tools in Detecting Malignant Thyroid Nodules
Background: Nodular thyroid disease is a common disorder and its incidence increases with age. They are
three to four times more common in females than in males. The main risk of such nodules is the possibility
of malignancy. In past decades, palpable thyroid nodules (TNs) were surgically excised to establish a tissue
diagnosis, and in some instances completion thyroidectomy was needed if malignancy was detected which
means more morbidity to the patients. On the same time the incidence of tissue diagnosed cancers in these
nodules ranged from 12-20%; therefore it is logic to propose a more selective policy in choosing patients
with thyroid nodules for whom surgery is required. Recently, advances in two diagnostic tools; namely
ultrasonography (US) and fine-needle aspiration cytology (FNAC), and more recently the combination of
both (Sonar Guided FNAC) served to revolutionize the treatment of TNs and to reduce the number of
unnecessary surgeries for nodules that are predictably benign. Aim of the work: It was to evaluate the
utility of the commonly used preoperative diagnostic tools in detecting malignancy in patients with TNs
scheduled for surgery in our hospital by comparing its results to that of the gold standard investigation
(postoperative histopathology). Patients and Methods: In General Surgery Department, Faculty of
medicine, Zagazig University Hospitals, Zagazig, Egypt; one hundred patients with thyroid nodules were
included in this study in the period from April 2012 to June 2016. They were 68 females and 32 males with
mean age of 40.77±14.9. Complete clinical, laboratory and ultrasonographic examinations were carried
out for all patients but sonar guided FNAC was done only for patients who accepted it. CT examination
was ordered for patients with clinically suspicious malignant TNs. After making the preoperative diagnosis
for each patient; the suitable thyroid surgery was carried out and the preoperative diagnosis was
compared to the postoperative histopathologic one. Results were statistically analyzed using SPSS version
20 and showed: the largest number of patients with TNs (35%) presented in the fourth decade of life while
the lowest one presented in the age group below 20 years (1%). Histopathologically, 39% of cases were
found to have malignant TNs and the remaining 61% had non- malignant TNs and the most frequent
malignant lesion was papillary carcinoma 79.5% followed by follicular carcinoma 10.3% and the most
frequent benign lesion was colloid nodules 54.1% followed by follicular adenoma 23%. The sensitivity,
specificity and accuracy rates of US were 92.3%, 44.3% and 63.0% and those of CT were 88.0%, 43.5%
and 66.7%, while those of FNAC were 100.0%, 97.6% and 98.6% respectively. Conclusion: There is a
quite high prevalence of malignant nodules in patients suffering from nodular thyroid disease. US has an
integral role in preoperative evaluation of TNs as well as long-term post treatment follow-up. Sonar guided
FNAC is a safe, easy, quick to perform, highly sensitive and accurate tool in diagnosing thyroid
malignancy and plays a crucial role in the selection of patients with TNs for operation. It is readily
repeatable, and has excellent patient compliance. So, all thyroid swellings should be thoroughly
investigated for malignancy considering FNAC.
Key wards: Nodular thyroid disease, Ultrasound, Fine Needle Aspiration Cytology and Thyroid
malignancy.