Amr Abdulbaky, Ahmed Elmahrouky
AmrAbdulbaky, Ahmed Elmahrouky, Ahmed Sayed, Ahmed Gamal
Ashrf Abo-Elftooh Khalil, Ahmed F. AboRady, Ahmed Nawwar, Ahmed Ragab Morsi
Khaled E. Soliman M.D, Medhat M. Anwar M.D, Yasser S. Ahmed M.D, Samy E. Ibrahim M.D, Moustafa M. Abd El-Baki M.D, Mohamed H. Sultan M.Sc.
Hisham Mostafa (MD)1 , Usama Lotfi (MD, MRCS)1 , Ahmed Abdulrahman (MSc) 2
Mohamed El-Maadawy, MD, Ahmed Gamal, MD & Usama Lotfi, MD
Mahmoud S. Elbasiouny
Ahmed El-Marakby¹, Ahmed Faragaly¹
Hossam Elmahdy, M.D, Walied Eldaly, M.D, Baker Ghoneim, M.D
Dina Hany1,*, MD, Wafi Fouad2,*, MD and Ramy Mikhael Nageeb1,*, MD
Dina Hany1,*, MD, Wafi Fouad2,*, MD and Ramy Mikhael Nageeb1,*, MD
Khaled E. Soliman1 , Noha M. Ragab2 , Omar Shebl Zahra3
1Emad Abdellatif Daoud1M.D and 2Dahlia M. Dalam, M.D
Mohamed Riad and Basem M. Sieda
Ahmed Mahmoud Hussein1MD; Nader Makram Milad1MD; Mohammed Diaa Sarhan 1 MD; Ahmed Shaddad Abdel Wahed2 M.Sc.
1Gamal El Zaiady, 2Rasha Abdelkader, 2Sameh El Noamani
Ahmed A. Nawar, Rasha Abdelkader, Fady M. Yacoub
Abdrabou N. Mashhour MD
1Amr Saleh Elbahaey, 2Ahmed Aly Radwan
A Randomized Controlled Trial Comparing Harmonic Scalpel and Electrocautery Dissection in Modified Radical Mastectomy
Background: Modified radical mastectomy (MRM) remains the most commonly performed operative
procedure for breast cancer today. Conventional MRM using electrocautery or scalpel is associated with a
moderate degree of operative morbidity. Ultrasonic dissection using the harmonic scalpel has recently
emerged as a safe alternative to electrocautery. Aim: To test the hypothesis that the use of a harmonic
scalpel results in less estimated blood loss, postoperative pain, drainage volume, and duration of surgery,
as well as fewer complications, such as flap necrosis, seroma, and surgical site infection, than conventional
electrocautery without prolonging the operative time. Methods: A prospective randomized single blinded
controlled study in which the operative and postoperative details of twenty breast cancer patients who
underwent modified radical mastectomy for pathologically proven breast cancer using the harmonic
scalpel (group A) were compared with twenty matched controls operated with electrocautery (group B) in
Ain shams university hospitals between April 2014 and march 2016. Results: There was no significant
difference in the operating time between the harmonic scalpel and electrocautery group (108 and 112.5
mins, p 0.924). The blood loss (100-170 ml) as compared to electrocautery group (250-350 ml) and
drainage volume (300-450 ml) in group A versus (600-800 ml) in group B; were significantly lower
(p<0.001) in the harmonic scalpel group. Also, statistically significant lower postoperative pain in the
harmonic group was documented. There was a significant reduction of drain days in harmonic scalpel
group (average 4 vs 8.5 days). There was no significant difference in the wound complications rate between
two groups. Conclusion: Modified radical mastectomy using harmonic scalpel is feasible and significantly
reduces the blood loss and duration of drainage as compared to electrocautery.