Ahmed Abd Al Aziz, MD1, Nader Sh. Zaki, MD2,Karim G. Moustafa, MD3, M. Fathy Elshaal
Abdrabou N Mashhour, Haitham S.E. Omar, Ramy S. Abdelkader.
Hany MS Mikhail, Mohamed M Raslan, Mohamed Y Elbarmelgi, Ramy S. Abdelkader
Adel Morad Abdallah (M.D.)
Ahmed S.M. Omar, MD
H. Said1, Ahmed Khalil1, Ahmed Fathy Hilal2
Ragai S. Hanna1, George Abdelfady Nashed2, Gamal A Makhlouf 3, Nahed A Makhlouf 4, Manal El Sayed Abdelmooty 5
Ragai S. Hanna1 , George Abdelfady Nashed2,Ashraf, A Helmy 3, Gamal A Makhlouf4, Emad Z.K. Said5, Abdelraouf MS Abdelraouf 6
Ramy Mikhael Nageeb1, *, MD, and Shaban M. Abdel Mageed2, *, MD
Shawki M.K Sharouda1*; Ramy Mikhael Nageeb2*; MD and Shaban M. Abdel Mageed1*, MD
Sherif Abdel Halim MD, MRCS, Hanna Habib MD, Hossam Elsadek MD
Ahmed Morad, MD; Wael A Jumuah, MD; Hanna Habib, MD
Yasser El Ghamrini, MD. Karim Sabry Abdel Samee, MD, MRCS(Ed), Wael Abdel Aziem Gumuah, MD.
Anas Mashal MD; Abdallah Magdy MD,FRCS
Anas Mashal MD, *Abdallah Abdelwahed MD;**Hady Saleh Abou-Ashour, MD,MRCS
A Comparative Study between Oncoplastic Breast Surgery and Standard Conservative Surgery: Margin status and Patient Satisfaction among Egyptian Females
Background: The two main goals (locoregional control and cosmetic results) usually don’t meet together in
standard conservative breast surgery. This opens the third way in which plastic techniques were integrated with
oncological procedures and termed oncoplastic breast surgery. Objective: The study aimed to assess the
oncological safety of oncoplastic surgery especially the margin status and its impact on patient satisfaction.
Patients and Methods: We prospectively conduct this study on 70 female patients with breast cancer,
Those were partitioned into 2 equal groups: group A (35patients) who underwent standard conservative,
group B (35patients) who underwent oncoplastic surgery. Results: The mean margin width was 16.2±7.6
mm (1.0 – 33.0 mm) in oncoplastic group versus 9.7±7.4mm (ranges 0.0–24mm) in standard group, p-value
<0.001. Only one patient (2%) reported distortion in the treated breast in the oncoplastic group versus 7
patients (20%) in standard group. Nearly 94% in the oncoplastic group said that if they could choose again
they will consider the same procedure versus 16 patients (45.7%) in standard group. Conclusion: Most
likely, oncoplastic surgery open the way for challenging tumors in troublesome areas, Permitting us to
have a broad resections, accordingly, adding more oncological safety without compromising the
restorative results.
Keywords: Oncoplastic surgery, wide margins, local recurrence, oncological safety, patient satisfaction.