Abdelrahman M. Gameel MD, Hosam A. Tawfek MD.
GehanG. Ali1, Laila Rawash1, Shaban M. Abdelmageed2, and Shawki M.K Sharouda2
Ahmad Abd Al Aziz,MD; Ahmed Mahmoud Hussein MD
Ahmed Abd Al Aziz MD*, Salah Said Soliman MD**, Mohamed M Raslan MD***
Osama Ahmed Radwan
Ahmed Abdelsalam Hafiz (M.D)*, Youssif Khachaba(M.D)*, Ashraf Elsebaiae Mohammed(M.D)*, Waleed Adel (M.D)**
Mahmoud Farghaly, MD Ahmed Morad, MD Tarek Youssef, MD, MRCS, FACS
1Hossam El sayed El shafey MD, MRCS and 2Waledd Agawee MD
Mohamed E. Elsherbeni MD, A. Elboushi MD.
Tamer Yassin1, Wesam Mohamed1, Ahmed A Youssef2
Wesam Mohamed, Tamer Yassin, Ayman Hussein, Mahmoud El shahawy, Alaa Obeida
Mohamed M. Raslan
Ahmed Sobhy Abbass Ahmed Elsobky
Laparoscopic Versus Open Approach in Management of hepatic Hydatid Cystic Disease
Introduction: Hydatid disease has a worldwide distribution and commonly seen in sheep rearing areas.
Tapeworm of genus Echinococcus is the parasite causing the disease. The most common site of involvement
is the Liver. Treatment options are medical therapy, percutaneous drainage, or surgical intervention.
Objective: Assessment of the outcome of either laparoscopic or open surgical treatment of liver hydatid
cyst. Patients and methods: 48 patients with liver hydatid cysts underwent either laparoscopic or open
surgical approach under cover of albendazol therapy. Both were divided in two groups according to the
procedure done. The data collected were demographic data, Laboratory results, Radiological tests, type of
surgical internvention, and post operative data. Results: The study involved 25 male and 23 females with a
mean age of 36.76. Twenty patients (41.66%) had laparoscopic approach and 28 patients (58.34%) had
open approach. Forty sex patients had one cyst and 2 patients had 2 cysts (P-value= 0.787). According to
type of Operative Procedure: Deroofing was done in 38 patients, while Resection was done in 8 patients.
Only 2 patients had Peri-cystectomy. With respect to Packing of the cyst with omentum, it was applied in 23
patients of open approach group and 9 patients of laparoscpic approach group (P-value= 0.013). The
mean time of operation in the laparoscopic group was 74.75± 18.67 minutes while in the open group was
92.24±20.94 minutes (P-value=0.004). Conclusion: Hydatid Cystic lesions of the liver can be treated
either by Laparoscopic or open surgical techniques with similar outcomes but with superiority of the
laparoscopy due to less operative time and hospital stay.
Keywords; hepatic hydatid cyst, laparoscopy, deroofing, recurrence.